RanestaExclusive Real Estate
DE

The places

Waterfront, mountain, city

The three kinds of prime asset behave differently in a cycle, cost differently to hold and sell to different people. Which one you are buying matters more than where.

The places8 min read
Waterfront, mountain, city

Ask a desk what it sells and it will say houses. Ask a family office what it buys and it will say one of three things: water, mountain or city. The distinction sounds like geography and is actually about how the asset behaves: what makes it scarce, who wants it, what it costs to keep, and what happens to it when the money gets nervous.

Water

Frontage is the scarcest thing in property because coastlines do not grow and planning has stopped building on them. A cape estate on the Riviera, a lakefront villa on Como, a frontline house in the southwest of Mallorca, a bayfront on the Miami islands: each is one of a fixed number, and the number falls whenever one is bought by a family that never sells. Water holds value through every cycle for that reason, and it is the asset blind listings are written for.

It is also the most expensive to hold. Salt, wind, the seawall, the dock, the insurance on a hurricane coast, the garden that needs water in August. And it is seasonal in the Mediterranean in a way that a city apartment is not, which is why the letting income matters and why the own-or-rent arithmetic is honest here.

Mountain

The alpine markets on this site, St. Moritz and Kitzbühel, are scarce by law rather than by geography. Switzerland stopped new holiday homes in 2012 and rations foreign buyers with a quota; Tyrol restricts second homes and checks. The result is the same as water: a fixed stock and a growing number of people who want it. Mountain assets are the least liquid on the list, three hundred days to sell a Suvretta chalet, and the most stable, because nobody who owns one needs to sell it in a hurry.

They are held in francs or in a jurisdiction with a flat exit tax, which changes the arithmetic; they are cheap to run relative to their price; and they have two seasons, which is one more than the coast.

City

A floor in the 7th, a lateral in Mayfair, a villa in Herzogpark, a palace floor inside the Ring. City assets are scarce by address: the number of Haussmann floors with a view of the dome is fixed, but the number of very good apartments in Paris is large, and the market is deep, liquid and priced by comparables. Cities are cheapest to hold in Europe, most expensive in America, most liquid everywhere, and least prone to the ten-week-season problem. They are also where the currency question lives, because London and New York are priced in someone else's money.

Scarcity
Water: geography. Mountain: law. City: address, within a deep market.
Liquidity
Water: a year for the best. Mountain: a year and a permit. City: months, weeks for a well-priced floor.
Holding cost
Water: highest, and insured. Mountain: moderate, in francs. City: lowest in Europe, highest in America.
In a downturn
Water: frontline loses least and recovers first. Mountain: barely trades. City: falls with the market and recovers with the economy.
Who buys
Water: collectors and seasonal residents. Mountain: collectors and legacy builders. City: relocators, offices and investors.

A family should own one of each and know which is which. Most own two of one and call it diversification.

The portfolio instrument, in a sentence

Mixing them

The desk's office mandates tend to end with a city floor for the base, a water house for the summer and, where the family skis, a mountain chalet held for the grandchildren. Three assets, three currencies sometimes, three holding-cost profiles, three exit regimes. The portfolio instrument shows what each addition does to the share of wealth in property and how fast the whole position could be sold, which for water and mountain is slowly.

Run the numbers

Portfolio Balance

What the next house does to the share of your wealth in property, and how fast you could sell it all.

Open the instrument

Read next

The hotspot cycleThe places

The hotspot cycle

Prime markets do not move together. Dubai has fallen forty per cent twice; the Gold Coast of Zürich has not fallen in living memory. How the cycle works at the top, and how to buy through it.

The holding cost nobody budgetsThe numbers

The holding cost nobody budgets

A house costs something every year whether you are in it or not. The lines that make up the bill, where they are large, and the two that are invisible until the first year's end.

The Private Letter

One letter a month.

One letter a month: what moved in the hotspots, one anonymised sale explained, one number worth knowing. No advertising, no tracking, one click to leave.